Fitbit vs FuelBand: Which Fitness Tracker Is Better?

a woman with fitness tracker stretching - Comparing Fitbit vs FuelBand

The Fitbit vs Fuelband comparison can be as confusing as any other technology-related discussion. We’re talking about those fitness tracker things everyone is wearing, right? My neighbor has one. That woman on “American Housewife” wears two. Is it a step counter, a pedometer, or a fitness tracker? The reality is, they’re all in a single category: things you need to know more about.

Who can forget when step counters took the world by storm? Suddenly, everyone was comparing their daily numbers. More recently, sports watches took it to a new level. Now there are a plethora of wearable activity trackers, and the lines keep getting blurrier. What features are out there? Which are actually worth paying for? Is there a particular tracking app that I simply must have?

Fitbit vs FuelBand

Fitbit-Logo nike fuelband logo

Fitbit is one of the most popular brands in the business. Their products have helped people count steps and burn calories for many years. Nike’s FuelBand launched in 2012 to rival this giant and utilized more gamification. Let’s see how they compare.

Fitbit Charge 3

Fitbit Charge 3 Fitness Activity Tracker, Graphite/Black, One Size (S & L Bands Included)
  • Better measure calorie burn, understand resting heart rate & more with 24/7 heart rate tracking and a battery life of up to 7 days (varies with use and other factors); Charge time (0 to100 percent) 2 hours
  • Choose from 15 plus exercise modes like run, bike, swim, yoga, circuit training and more, set a goal, and get real time stats during your workouts to see how you can keep getting better
  • Automatically record time spent in Light, Deep and REM sleep stages and see activity trends, health insights and personalized guidance in one place with Fitbit Today
  • Swim proof and water resistant to 50 Meters so you can track swims and wear in the shower; We do not recommend wearing Charge 3 in a hot tub or sauna; Also connect to smartphone GPS for real time pace and distance during outdoor runs and rides
  • Stay connected to your day with everyday apps for weather and more and get call, text and smartphone app notifications on your wrist; Small wristband Fits a wrist between 5.5 to 7.1 inches; Large wristband Fits a wrist between 7.1 to 8.7 inches

This is the latest Fitbit and comes with a wide range of sensors and functions. We’ve chosen it for this Fitbit vs FuelBand comparison because it’s in the same price range as the FuelBand.

Technical Specs

Weight

1.27 ounces

Trackers

Heartrate, 3-axis accelerometer, altimeter, relative SPO2, vibration motor, sleep, calories

Display

Grayscale OLED touchscreen

Battery life

Up to 7 days

Max. altitude

28,000 feet

Includes

Small and large wristband

Charging cable

The Fitbit Charge 3 is waterproof up to 50 meters and can handle temperatures between -4 and 113 degrees Fahrenheit. It takes two hours to charge the battery to full capacity. It saves detailed data for seven days, updating each minute. Daily summaries are available for 30 days. Heart rate registers every second during exercise, and every five when you’re not exercising. The Charge 3 can sync automatically with smartphones, computers, and tablets up to 20 feet away using Bluetooth LE.

You get a variety of customizable, goal-based exercises for motivation. There’s also a guided breathing function for meditation and such. It even has a feature that helps women track their monthly cycle.

Pricing

You can get a Fitbit Charge 3 for between $120 and $160. Considering its robust build and many features, that’s an agreeable price.

What people think

Users say they like the long battery life, the comfortable fit and weight, the plethora of features, and its app integration. Some buyers find the software somewhat limiting and buggy, while others wish for more clock faces. However, an update should take care of those issues. Users give it 3.3 out of 5 stars on Amazon.

Pros and cons

Pros

  • Lots of features
  • Water-proof
  • Detailed tracking
  • Long memory

Cons

  • Software isn’t perfect
  • Limited clock faces

If you’re looking for a feature-packed lightweight activity tracker, a Fitbit Charge 3 is a solid choice. It covers all the basics and more.

It won’t show you the date, and it may act up around other Bluetooth devices. Overall, it stands up well to sports watches and activity trackers in its price range.

Nike+ FuelBand

Nike+ FuelBand White Ice X-Large
  • Measures your everyday activity and turns it into NikeFuel, a universal metric of activity
  • Tracks calories burned, steps taken and tells time
  • Displays your progress in real time
  • Keeps you motivated through daily goals and achievements

The original Nike+ FuelBand provides activity tracking that syncs with the Nike+ online community for comparison and community. It aims to gamify your exercise by setting goals and giving points. However, please note that Nike discontinued it in 2014.

Technical Specs

Weight

1 ounce

Trackers

Pedometer, accelerometer, calorie counter, NikeFuel

Display

20-color red/green LED, 100 white LED

Battery life

Up to 8 days

Max. altitude

Not stated

Includes

Charging cord

2 wrist links

The FuelBand converts your daily data into NikeFuel. These points unlock achievements and awards on the Nike+ online community. The device itself is splash-proof but can’t handle submersion. While it did originally have many features, the FuelBand is now mostly inoperable, and you can’t reset its memory the normal way.

Pricing

While some still sell it for around $150, you can get one for as little as $30 to $40. However, without the online service, there’s no way to set a new Fuelband up.

What people think

Users liked the sleek, simplistic activity tracker and the way it helped with motivation. However, most complain about the lack of support and functionality since its discontinuation. Concerning Fitbit vs FuelBand, this is a crucial factor. Thus, it has 3.1 out of 5 stars on Amazon.

Pros and Cons

Pros

  • Cheaper
  • Smaller
  • More user-friendly

Cons

  • Discontinued
  • No functional software

It’s hard, to sum up the good parts of a product that no longer works. But that’s what people had to say in the past.

No version of Nike+ FuelBand works anymore. That’s a big drawback if there ever was one.

Who Should Buy a Fitbit Charge 3

Anyone who wants a versatile activity tracker with fun, helpful features can benefit from a Fitbit Charge 3. However, if you need a VO2 max reading, you’ll want to look at another product. That’s the only significant performance feature that’s missing. Due to the female health feature, the Fitbit Charge 3 is an excellent choice for women, in particular.

Who Should Buy a Nike FuelBand

It’s hard to recommend the FuelBand to anyone now since Nike has abandoned the wearable gadget market. However, I can advise you to look at the Apple Watch Nike+ if you’re interested. Regarding Fitbit vs FuelBand, it’s a simple matter.

Apple Watch Nike+ 42mm Silver Aluminum Case Pure Platinum/White Nike Sport Band
  • Aluminum Case With Nike Sport Band
  • Heart Rate Sensor / Wi-Fi / Bluetooth 4.0 / Built-in GPS
  • Water Resistant 50 Meters
  • Up To 18 Hours Of Battery Life / Magnetic Charging Cable

Final Thoughts on Fitbit vs FuelBand

Product

Details

Rating

Price

Fitbit Charge 3

Fitbit Charge 3

Weight1.27 ouncesTrackersHeartrate, 3-axis accelerometer, altimeter, relative SPO2, vibration motor, sleep, caloriesDisplayGrayscale OLED touchscreenBattery lifeUp to 7 daysMax. altitude28,000 feetIncludesSmall and large wristbandCharging cableWaterproofUp to 50 metersTemperature capability-4 and 113 degrees FahrenheitConnectivityAutomatic sync with smartphones, PCs, and tabletsBluetooth LE

3.3 out of 5.0

Check Price

Nike+ FuelBand

Nike+ FuelBand

Weight1 ounceTrackersPedometer, accelerometer, calorie counter, NikeFuelDisplay20-color red/green LED, 100 white LEDBattery lifeUp to 8 daysIncludesCharging cord, 2 wrist linksOther FeaturesSplash-proof

3.1 out of 5.0

Check Price

Due to the discontinuation, the verdict on Fitbit vs FuelBand is simple. The Fitbit is the clear winner. If you don’t feel like you need all those features, there are simpler Fitbits available too.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here